Does Apple Watch Overestimate Calories Burned?
In September 2023, Apple unveiled its latest wearable addition, the Apple Watch Series 9. With a design and set of features identical to its predecessor, the Apple Watch Series 8, it preserves the same health and fitness tracking capabilities.
Every stride, every heartbeat during sleep, or the detailed stats on your hike — all can be logged with meticulous precision, thanks to the advanced functionalities of Watch OS 10.
However, as impressive as this all sounds, a burning question persists in the minds of its users or potential users - Does Apple Watch overestimate calories burned during these activities?
While no fitness tracker, even the newest high-tech Apple Watch, can claim a 100% accuracy rate in monitoring calories burned, the reasons behind the apparent overestimation by Apple Watch, and its implications, are worth a deeper dive.
That why in this blog post, Fitstraps will investigate these aspects, comparing the accuracy of the Apple Watch with other devices on the market, exploring the potential issues, and discussing whether the data can truly guide dietary adjustments.
How Does Apple Watch Calorie Tracking Work?
Apple Watch employs an advanced system for the effective tracking of calories. This is accomplished through a combination of motion sensors, heart rate monitoring, and personalized health data.
The device meticulously monitors your movements, distinguishing between regular movements and more strenuous exercises. This distinction is crucial, as the latter is associated with burning active calories.
The device's heart rate sensor complements the motion sensors by providing essential data about the intensity of your workouts. The watch intelligently integrates all of this information with your personal health details like age, weight, and gender to deliver an accurate estimate of the calories you've burned throughout the day.
In addition, the Apple Watch also tracks your passive or resting calories, which are the calories your body burns naturally throughout the day, even when inactive.
This figure is calculated based on something known as your basal metabolic rate— the amount of energy your body needs to maintain its essential functions like breathing and circulation.
By summing up both resting and active calories, the Apple Watch is able to present the user with a comprehensive overview of your total calories expenditure.
How Accurate are the Calories Burned Readings on the Apple Watch?
The Apple Watch utilizes a blend of algorithms and sensor data to produce its calorie burn estimates, making them reasonably accurate for a wrist-worn device. However, it's important to note that no consumer device can deliver data with perfect precision.
The watch takes into account your personal details such as age, weight, and gender, as well as the intensity of your physical activity. It also factors in your resting energy expenditure, calculated using your basal metabolic rate.
Despite the sophistication of this technology, variables such as individual metabolic variations and the limitation of sensors can introduce some margin of error.
Therefore, while the Apple Watch offers a solid estimation of calories burned, it should only be used as a guide to inform your health decisions rather than an absolute measure.
Apple Watch's Activity Tracking Compared with Other Fitness Trackers
The Apple Watch has actually been found to overestimate the number of calories burned when compared to other wearable devices on the market.
This discrepancy can largely be attributed to the device's tendency to provide higher estimates for high-intensity activities and underestimations during fast-paced walking exercises.
Comparatively, Garmin activity trackers are generally more consistent in their step tracking, although they tend to fall short in accurately estimating speed, elevation, and sleep.
Similarly, while the Withings ScanWatch shows impressive accuracy in determining step count and relative energy expenditure, its heart rate measurements during active tasks are less accurate.
It's worth noting that while these devices can estimate energy expenditure and provide a general understanding of activity levels, they may not be suitable for situations that demand more precise measurements.
Main Reasons Behind These Inaccuracies
There are several reasons why your Apple Watch may be providing inaccurate data regarding your calorie burn calculations. These inaccuracies can lead to a lack of accuracy in energy expenditure tracking and potentially hinder your exercise goals.
Here, we will discuss the main reasons behind these inconsistencies and how you can address them.
Exercise Conditioning and Calorie Calculation
One of the primary reasons for inaccurate calorie calculations is due to exercise conditioning. It's common for our bodies to become accustomed to certain exercises over time, making them easier and less physically taxing.
However, this also means that the actual calories burned may decrease as your body becomes more efficient at performing the same activities. To combat this, it is important to vary your workouts and challenge yourself with new exercises.
The Pitfall of Inaccurate Data Input
Another reason could be due to entering inaccurate or fewer data points. When setting up your Apple Watch, it is essential to enter your correct height, weight, and age for accurate calorie calculations.
Additionally, be diligent in tracking all of your workouts and activities with the device so that it has enough data points to accurately estimate your calories burned.
Complications Arising from Poor Watch Fit
The fit of your Apple Watch and band can also play a role in inaccurate calorie calculations.
If your watch is not snug on your wrist, it may move around too much during workouts, leading to less accurate results.
Make sure to adjust the Apple Watch band for a secure fit before starting any exercise.
The Problem of Miscalibrations
Lastly, if you have recently updated or reset your Apple Watch, it may need calibration. This process ensures that the device's sensors are working accurately and can provide more precise measurements with the Apple Health app.
To calibrate your Apple Watch, you will need to perform an outdoor run or walk for at least 20 minutes with both the watch and iPhone in hand.
Tracking your exercise progress with an Apple Watch can be helpful, but it is essential to be aware of potential inaccuracies and how to address them.
Ensuring Accurate Calorie Calculations on Your Apple Watch
To ensure that your Apple Watch provides accurate calorie calculations, there are several steps you can take:
Just as a car needs routine maintenance for optimal performance, your Apple Watch requires regular calibration to maintain as much accuracy as possible. This involves updating the device with your personal information, such as age, gender, height and weight, which it uses to calculate your calorie expenditure.
Ensure a Snug Fit:
Always wear your Apple Watch Band snugly on the top of your wrist. The sensors always work best when the watch is neither too loose nor too tight.
Appropriate Workout Selection:
When beginning any form of exercise, ensure you select the appropriate workout app on your Apple Watch. This allows the device to accurately track the specific movements and calories data associated with that activity.
Mindful of Tattoos:
Did you know that certain tattoos may interfere with the Apple Watch’s sensors? The ink, pattern, and saturation of some tattoos can block the watch's light sensors, leading to unreliable readings.
Enable Wrist Detection Feature:
On your Apple Watch, make sure that the Wrist Detection feature is turned on. This ensures that your watch will be able to detect when you are wearing it and adjust its tracking accordingly.
Consider Using Bluetooth Chest Straps:
If you want an even more accurate heart rate measurement during a workout, consider using a Bluetooth chest strap in addition to your Apple Watch. These straps record the wearer's heart rate data directly from the chest, providing a more accurate reading than the wrist-based sensors.
By following these steps, you can help your Apple Watch provide more accurate data on calories burned, ultimately enabling you to better track your fitness progress.
Can You Rely on Apple Watch’s Calories Burned Data to Adjust Your Diet?
The short answer is: not entirely. It's important to remember that the Apple Watch is a fitness tracker, not a medical device. While it can provide an estimate of how many calories you burn throughout the day, there are many factors that can affect these calorie estimates. For example, the Apple Watch does not take into account factors such as genetics, age, hormonal changes, and stress levels which can all impact your metabolism and calorie burning.
Therefore, it is best to use the Apple Watch's calorie data as a general guide rather than a precise measurement to build your lifestyle around. It can still be helpful in tracking your overall activity levels and providing motivation to stay active, but it should not be relied upon as the sole source of information for adjusting your diet.
An alternative way is to monitor your weight and adjust your diet accordingly. By consistently tracking your actual weight and predicted calorie deficit, you can better understand how your body responds to different levels of activity and make adjustments as needed to lose weight faster (if that is what you are looking to do of coarse).
The basic principle for weight loss is to consume fewer calories than you burn, and the Apple Watch can certainly assist in this process by providing estimates of your calorie expenditure. However, it's important to remember that weight loss is not just about counting calories burned during an activity, but also about maintaining a balanced and healthy diet.
While the Apple Watch calories data can provide valuable insights into your calorie expenditure, it should be used in conjunction with other methods and should not be solely relied upon for making significant dietary changes.
Elevate Your Style with FitstrapsUK's Apple Watch Bands
At FitstrapsUK, we pride ourselves on offering a wide variety of Apple Watch straps, thoughtfully designed to match any style or occasion. Our bands are not only functional but also fashionable, helping you to stand out in a crowd and express your unique personality.
Whether you're heading to the gym, going to work, or dressing up for a night out, we have the perfect band to complement your outfit. Don't settle for ordinary - step up your game with FitstrapsUK's exceptional range of Apple Watch bands.
Give your watch a new look and experience the impressive quality we offer. Make the smart choice - choose FitstrapsUK, and let your Apple watch be an extension of your style.